Solid Whey vs. ATW vs. EAS MyoPro

Printable View

02-24-2005, 03:56 PM
wired-up

Solid Whey vs. ATW vs. EAS MyoPro

It's about time to order more protein. I have used strawberry and vanillia EAS Myo Pro Protein in the past and both were great. The last batch of protein was from ATW. I got the chocolate, vanillia, strawberry, and orange concentrate blends. The chocolate was my favorite. I am interested in trying the Solid Whey protein from http://www.allsportsnutrition.com/ I'm looking for people that have tried it in comparison to the EAS and ATW. The actual flavor of the ATW was good in all varieties, but I really didn't like the texture of it. It was too thick and fluffy for my tastes. By the end of the shake, it was almost gagging. The EAS (along with another brand I can't remember) was a lot smoother than the ATW. I don't plan to ever buy ATW again. Good protein, but just too dang thick! So let me hear from you if you've tried the Solid Whey. :hello:
02-24-2005, 10:33 PM
fritz2435

ATW orange works for me... maybe your not adding enough water?
02-24-2005, 10:38 PM
wired-up

Quote:

Originally Posted by fritz2435

ATW orange works for me... maybe your not adding enough water?

if i add water till the consistency is like the Myo Pro, then the flavor is way too watered down. looking for people's experience with Solid Whey in comparison to the other 2. ATW orange TASTES good, but ATW is too thick in general.
02-24-2005, 10:39 PM
BDTR

I happen to like the taste of solid whey compared to ATW and EAS.
02-24-2005, 10:43 PM
wired-up

Quote:

Originally Posted by bdtr

I happen to like the taste of solid whey compared to ATW and EAS.

but how is the consistency, the thickness compared to ATW and EAS? that's the main thing i'm looking for, not the taste.
02-24-2005, 10:48 PM
BDTR

It's pretty thin, not like water but less clumpy than ATW IMO.
02-24-2005, 10:57 PM
wired-up

Quote:

Originally Posted by bdtr

It's pretty thin, not like water but less clumpy than ATW IMO.

great, so in comparison to EAS and ATW, the solid whey is more like EAS?
02-25-2005, 12:20 AM
KGBnine

solid mixes better than any other protein I've tried. But I've never had ATW or EAS.
02-25-2005, 05:51 AM
bigsd67

though you didnt mention it i have also tried the optimum whey and it mixes very well..you can get 10lbs of it from allsports for a good price as well.
02-25-2005, 07:49 AM
wired-up

Quote:

Originally Posted by bigsd67

though you didnt mention it i have also tried the optimum whey and it mixes very well..you can get 10lbs of it from allsports for a good price as well.

i don't like optimum. that's the main reason i didn't mention it. :rolleyes:
02-25-2005, 08:22 AM
SwoleCat

Depends on what macro breakdown you need.

ATW's isolate fits what I need perfectly. The others don't, too much fat/carbs.

~SC~
02-25-2005, 08:29 AM
wired-up

Quote:

Originally Posted by SwoleCat

Depends on what macro breakdown you need.

ATW's isolate fits what I need perfectly. The others don't, too much fat/carbs.

~SC~

not overly concerned with them since i can adjust my diet the rest of the day to handle them. ATW blends are almost gagging they're so thick. the only time i drink the shakes is PMO, so the carbs are not a problem. the fat is only 4 grams for 2 scoops, which is negligible IMO compared to the protein and carbs you're already getting.

Swole, have you tried the blends as well? How does the thickness of the isolate compare to the blends?
02-25-2005, 09:16 AM
SplinterCell

All the Whey > All
02-25-2005, 09:30 AM
wired-up

Quote:

Originally Posted by SplinterCell

All the Whey > All

gonna have to disagree with you on that on. :stick:
02-25-2005, 11:04 AM
SwoleCat

Quote:

Originally Posted by wired-up

ATW blends are almost gagging they're so thick.

Uhhhh, use more water.

~SC~
02-25-2005, 02:57 PM
wired-up

Quote:

Originally Posted by SwoleCat

Uhhhh, use more water.

~SC~

then there's no flavor. that's my point. to get the blends to be the same thickness as EAS, you have to put a ton more water and then it has almost no flavor.
02-25-2005, 03:53 PM
SplinterCell

Quote:

Originally Posted by wired-up

gonna have to disagree with you on that on. :stick:

Just as long as you realize your wrong you can disagree all you want :D
02-25-2005, 03:55 PM
SplinterCell

Quote:

Originally Posted by wired-up

then there's no flavor. that's my point. to get the blends to be the same thickness as EAS, you have to put a ton more water and then it has almost no flavor.

I guess it's just preference then, me personally I want my shakes to have substance to them...the thicker the better.

40 grams of orange ATW + 80 grams of dex shaken for a minute and left in the fridge for an hour tastes better than pussy :cool:
02-25-2005, 03:57 PM
wired-up

Quote:

Originally Posted by SplinterCell

I guess it's just preference then, me personally I want my shakes to have substance to them...the thicker the better.

40 grams of orange ATW + 80 grams of dex shaken for a minute and left in the fridge for an hour tastes better than pussy :cool:

you need to get out more! :lol:
02-25-2005, 03:58 PM
SplinterCell

Quote:

Originally Posted by wired-up

you need to get out more! :lol:

While im out I might actually get to taste it...pussy that is :lol:
02-25-2005, 04:53 PM
fitnessNY

Solid whey is the best i have tried. I also used to use eas before I switched to solid whey.
02-25-2005, 09:10 PM
wired-up

Quote:

Originally Posted by fitnessNY

Solid whey is the best i have tried. I also used to use eas before I switched to solid whey.

how does the thickness of the two compare?