Puff's lyrics are "soft" (and dumb) but I would still argue the guy has more talent than most of the people you posted. Seriously, if it wasn't for the bangin instrumentals, no one would listen to rap. No one goes out and buys a CD thats just the "poetry" aspect of it, but they will pay for the rap to be drowned out by the kick-ass base groove put together by some producer whos name you likely will never hear. With some exceptions to that rule..........
Thats why I've never had a ton of respect for eminem. The guy can be creative, but hes nothing new really, hes predictable, and quite frankly, anyone can do it. Thats why most rappers who are just rapper (not owners of their own lable, etc) don't make as much anymore. Record companies can pay any black person with an accent and who doesn't seem like a total pussy (some exceptions there) to do what they do. Jadakiss can whine about how the artists are getting screwed, but quite frankly, hes lucky to be where he is. You think vinilla ice has talent? No. The guy got a DJ to make a nice beat to go with "ice ice baby" and look where he got to.
At least MC hammer could dance, thats all I have to say
I got to go. I'll be interested to see the replies when I get back though.