Good Game Vs. Good Looks (Online test)

[J-Dogg]

So I've decided I'm going to put this to the test. I've heard so many people say that good game is way more important than good looks. That if you have solid game, you can get what you want. While if you have good looks, you can scare girls off by making a fool of yourself.

I'm creating 2 fake myspace accounts to test this out. I've stolen some pictures of what I assume to be a really in shape, attractive gay guy in Las Vagas and made a myspace account using his pictures. He's going to be called "Cody" and he's just going to be a normal guy, nothing witty about him, lower income.

I'm trying to find pictures of a "not so" attractive guy, maybe one thats not in great shape but is exciting, and fun. Maybe he's in a band, or that's what I'll put. Lives a really intresting life, travels, super out going and always the center of attention.


I'm going to test it out, and the messages I send girls will reflect the personality of these young gents. I'm going to run the game on some of the same girls to test the responses.

Field reports to come, I'm going to have to wait a few weeks to accumulate a bunch of fake friends so the pages look legit.

[Deltasaurus]

good luck sounds interesting

[FallenWyvern]

Cool.

I believe this was all done empirically in the book Freakonomics.

[JiGGaMaN]

hahaha i already know the answer to this: If you are a good looking guy and have a decent personality you will get way hotter girls than an average looking person with a great personality. No need to test this as it is a fact.

[smokeyd]

shit the game is where its at, you can be a super good lookin guy and if you dont know how to talk shit your wont get near as much as a avg looking guy that can run game

[GT2]

shit the game is where its at, you can be a super good lookin guy and if you dont know how to talk shit your wont get near as much as a avg looking guy that can run game

I COMPLETELY agree.
But the best combo is when you're attractive AND have good game

[daem]

I COMPLETELY agree.
But the best combo is when you're attractive AND have good game

^^^^ Always worked for me!

[GT2]

^^^^ Always worked for me!

Amen brother.

[novastepp]

humor is just plain effective when it comes to women.

[gixxerboy1]

not a good test. Online shit like witts and humor dont come across as much as looks

[SWOLLL]

Luckily I was blessed with both!

[J-Dogg]

all right all right, I get it. Every guy on the internet benches 400lbs, is surrounded by the "V" cause he is super good looking, smart, rich AND runs smooth game!

[HommieDClown]

I got the humor part down, but the looks that something i rather not talk about.

[J-Dogg]

I've only got 12 friends on the "attractive" account. But messaged a girl (probably an 8) that seemed kind of "snobby" by the text in her "who i'd like to meet".

Did a standard question "why r u moving?".

Came home to 2 messages from her, she is moving because she just got her masters. Her second message was her phone number. A picture posted was of the guy holding his phone, the caption was "texting....what I do best".

Her message was, "you like to text.....XXX-XXX-XXXX"

This is kind of fun

[KatsMeow]

you have entirely too much time on your hands

[J-Dogg]

you have entirely too much time on your hands

I actually have very little time. I spend a few hours a night on the PC to wind down, I don't watch T.V.

Trying to figure out women is more exciting than watching a realality show like the rest of america.

[Pooks]

DAMN! I never got a reply like that...


****!

[J-Dogg]

I've only got 12 friends on the "attractive" account. But messaged a girl (probably an 8) that seemed kind of "snobby" by the text in her "who i'd like to meet".

Did a standard question "why r u moving?".

Came home to 2 messages from her, she is moving because she just got her masters. Her second message was her phone number. A picture posted was of the guy holding his phone, the caption was "texting....what I do best".

Her message was, "you like to text.....XXX-XXX-XXXX"

This is kind of fun

2 LAME messages later that "CODY" sent (the good looking guy) and "KC" (the girl-a 8-9) wants to stop by some time.

I replied to her messages about how my ex left me because my life was "too simple" and some stuff about my "social anxiety".

[thegodfather]

I hope you publish your findings...

[Gaspari1255]

hahaha i already know the answer to this: If you are a good looking guy and have a decent personality you will get way hotter girls than an average looking person with a great personality. No need to test this as it is a fact.

Couldn't have said it better myself..

[Polska]

If you're good looking you do not need much or any game to get/have sex with a girl. You do however, need a personality, if you want her to stick around. A girl will sleep with a good looking guy over an average/bad looking guy no question. But a girl will more than likely stay (long-term) with the average guy with a great personality over the good looking guy that's boring with no personality. There is one more thing that goes into the equation, which is basically how much value the guy holds in comparison to the girl. There could be a guy with a lot of value that does not have very good looks (personality, social status, fame, money). Ultimately the girl will go for the guy with the most value to her.

[Polska]

By the way I think you're wasting your time with this thing. The conclusion to your experiment is obvious. And neither of those guys is really you, so you can't exactly have KC or whatever her name is 'stop by some time'. Bummer

[JiGGaMaN]

all right all right, I get it. Every guy on the internet benches 400lbs, is surrounded by the "V" cause he is super good looking, smart, rich AND runs smooth game!

Except for the first part, thats a fairly accurate description of the average person on here.

[J-Dogg]

By the way I think you're wasting your time with this thing. The conclusion to your experiment is obvious. And neither of those guys is really you, so you can't exactly have KC or whatever her name is 'stop by some time'. Bummer

I think it is highly dependant on the girl in question.

[IronReload04]

you have entirely too much time on your hands

well what do you think.


who is going to get you

the good looking guy with average game

or

the average looking guy with as a game as good as the other guy looks?

[Phate]

hahaha i already know the answer to this: If you are a good looking guy and have a decent personality you will get way hotter girls than an average looking person with a great personality. No need to test this as it is a fact.

sorry bro but you are dead wrong on that one, depends on individual circumstances but if you know what you are doing an average guy can blow a good looking guy out of the water everytime

[JiGGaMaN]

sorry bro but you are dead wrong on that one, depends on individual circumstances but if you know what you are doing an average guy can blow a good looking guy out of the water everytime

I disagree with that so much it makes me furious. Me and my friends watch my buddy act like a total ass and get hotter girls than us all the time. I have a good personality but im NEVER able to compete with him. lord knows i give it my damnedest though.

[J-Dogg]

I disagree with that so much it makes me furious. Me and my friends watch my buddy act like a total ass and get hotter girls than us all the time. I have a good personality but im NEVER able to compete with him. lord knows i give it my damnedest though.

That's kinda why I"m testing it.

I think on the "internet" looks are going to be way more important.

I have a good friend who I definatly feel is better looking than me. He's the same height as me but 20lbs larger and leaner. The guys a freak he's got viens in his lower abs all year and does not diet and lifts half ass.

He is however, not as smart as me, and not as comfortable approaching girls unless he is so wasted he say anything unless it is somthing obnoxious.

7 out of 10 times, I leave with a few numbers from quality girls. He gets numbers, but he gets them from MILFS and larger girls. My girls are always better looking than his.

I think on the internet, it's more look dependant though.

[WOLFCRAFT]

I'm a pretty good looking guy and I'm a complete prick with absolutely no game whatsoever.
And getting chicks is no problem at all.

Nice guy, great personality, interesting life, etc... FRIEND ZONE.

[WARMachine]

Let me put an end to all this...


Good looking guy w/ouy game scores 50% of chicks hit on.
Decent looking guy w/game scores about 50% of chicks hit on.
Good looking guy w/game scores 75% of chicks hit on.
Decent looking guy w/out game scores 5% of chicks hit on.




Good looking guy w/some game, and a fat bank account, scores 100% of chicks hit on!

Thats me! ^

Anyone listen to Tom Leykis for Gods sake? Im gonna start a new thread...

[Angel of death]

This thread is dumb. It completely depends. Good looking guys will get more girls. However, the "more" part are girls who go after looks obviously. A lot of girls go after looks. Some girls shoot for personality moreso. My sister, who is a very attractive girl, is about to marry a fat hairy Italian guy. HOWEVER...this guy is really cool and has a great personality. So to each their own.Ill tell you this though, when a girl is looking to settle down and think about a possible lifemate, personality does come heavily into play. As long as the guy isn't a complete mess and keeps himself at least in good hygeine.

[abbot138]

Cool.

I believe this was all done empirically in the book Freakonomics.

Awesome book! My vote is for Good game, although like someone said the combo would be best obviously.......But as a good looking guy, with very little "game" I can definately say that I would be knee deep in vagina if I had better "game." Allllthough that being said, the girl Im seeing right now is a serious piece of fvcking ass.....hmmm, this is a tough question Money trumps them all tho, lol.....I see ugly jerkoffs, with zero personality and a big bank roll with drop dead gorgeous girls all the time.

[abbot138]

Let me put an end to all this...


Good looking guy w/ouy game scores 50% of chicks hit on.
Decent looking guy w/game scores about 50% of chicks hit on.
Good looking guy w/game scores 75% of chicks hit on.
Decent looking guy w/out game scores 5% of chicks hit on.




Good looking guy w/some game, and a fat bank account, scores 100% of chicks hit on!Thats me! ^

Anyone listen to Tom Leykis for Gods sake? Im gonna start a new thread...

Ahhh, I see you already beat me to it....well said.

[Auss11e]

Let me put an end to all this...


Good looking guy w/ouy game scores 50% of chicks hit on.
Decent looking guy w/game scores about 50% of chicks hit on.
Good looking guy w/game scores 75% of chicks hit on.
Decent looking guy w/out game scores 5% of chicks hit on.




Good looking guy w/some game, and a fat bank account, scores 100% of chicks hit on!

Thats me! ^

Anyone listen to Tom Leykis for Gods sake? Im gonna start a new thread...

That adds up to 180%...............

[smokeyd]

has a lot to do with were your from also, small town big town what geographic area, think im joking well im not lol chunky guys get some good tang were im from and other places i go you wont ever see a bigger guy with a little hottie

[smokeyd]

That adds up to 180%...............

hahahaha it works 50% of the time, EVERY TIME

[abbot138]

Brian, I'm gonna be honest with you, that smells like pure gasoline.


LMAO!!! Ooops, wonrg thread, sorry.