Form a stricly physical stand point. Is it just me, but I luv my women on the thick side, too me a women with some healthy weight to her just makes them so much more attractive. I also can stand when a women drops to much fat. Makes them look unnatural and fragile. To me you have to be at least 130lbs. I even seen women 150lbs hold there weight tight due to some muscle on them. Muscle is much more dense then fat.