And by "masterpiece" I truly do mean masterpiece. Not just the best movie, or your favorite movie (though it may be both) but the film that you believe best encapsulates the best of all that which comprises brilliant filmmaking. So, not only should there be a kickass narrative, but the film should employ incredible camera work, near perfect casting, phenomenal dialogue, a superb soundtrack (that is appropriate for the film...no soundtracks for the sake of record sales), pertinent special effects, etc, etc. Upon nomination, defend your choice...this board isn't some mom and pop fly by night operation!
My nomination: Vanilla Sky (big surprsise)
I think this film truly tells a story that can not be effectively told through another medium...the surreal nature of the film just doesn't lend itself to orality, stage, or literature...truly a piece that could only be done in film and takes full advantage of the medium. The soundtrack is simply amazing and I can think of few other films that seem so perfectly cast. Where special effects are needed, they are nicely done without detracting from the film as a whole. The sets are next to flawless in the manner in which they almost serve as characters as the movie flows. I could go on and on in defense of this film. It's only weakness, and it does make it difficult for me to nominate it in some regards, is the fact that it is a pseudo-remake...that makes it a tough pick since pure originality is a criteria in my estimation. HOwever, the rest of the film is so brilliantly done that I ultimately have to give it my nod. Honorable mentions include Citizen Kane, Star Wars, Braveheart and the 25th Hour.
Reply With Quote
Originally Posted by RON
Thats a good one. 
!
