
Originally Posted by
MuscleInk
Interesting existential question. Years ago, minoring in philosophy as an undergrad in university, this was one of many discussions we had in and out of class. The whole idea of determinism often lead to debates with religious undertones (e.g. If god exists AND is an all knowing being as often characterized, then god knows every choice before we make it and hence our path/destiny is predetermined even if unknown to us - for if it was unknown to an omniscient being, then said being could not be omniscient and could not be god according to the criteria that god is n omniscient, omnipotent, omnipresent being).
I don't know that I believe in fate per se (and I certainly would NOT call myself religious by any stretch of the imagination) but I'm inclined to believe in karma, if the two can be mutually exclusive. Maybe it's superstitious but the idea of "what goes around, comes around", seems believable to me. Is that fate? If karma is simply a principal of causality where intent and actions of one, influence the future of THAT individual, is that fate?
I don't really know to be honest, but the idea of life being predetermined for each of us would be defeating in my mind. To think that my choices are in fact not made of my own volition and are in fact not choices at all but actions set in motion following a grand design is a little disappointing and underachieving for my liking.