Associate Member
you have a bench expert, and deadlift expert and both of them suck at their non expert lift. so who would win a fight?
i say the deadlifter, since the bench will try to use upper body while deadlifteer picks him up from his feet and drops him like a ton of bricks
Senior Member
deadlifts baby...anybody can bench press. Deadlifts take good more stability and I am kinda bias.
Anabolic Member
but then once they're on the ground, the bencher will just toss the deader right off of him.Originally Posted by synthetic
you have a bench expert, and deadlift expert and both of them suck at their non expert lift. so who would win a fight?
i say the deadlifter, since the bench will try to use upper body while deadlifteer picks him up from his feet and drops him like a ton of bricks
In actuality, the squatter would win. A simple kick in the groin from someone who squats 700+ and it's all over.. you're down. then a stomp on the head, and lights out forever.
Retired
Deadlifter, incorperates more of the body than anything. Oh and my best lift is the deadlift... 700 here i come.
Anabolic Member
there should be a link to the "how effective is a finger in your butt" thread right here...
ROTFLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLLL...
what about a curler and tricep extensioner... who would win that fight...or it would be a tie...
Anabolic Member
IMO a deadlifter would have the advantage due to the wider range of muscles used.
Anabolic Member
i think that would be a tie.....lol
how about a seated calf raiser vs a dumbell shrugger without straps?? now that would be a fight.....
Rosie Member
Deadlifter cause his got more raw power, he gets a hold of you and brake you in half.
Anabolic Member
or what about a sit uper vs. a treadmill junkie... this would be a battle
Anabolic Member
Banned
I think the tricep extensioner would win....Triceps make up much more of your arm. And for the deadlift,vs bench, deadlift would win IMO.
Senior Member
Deadlifter
Associate Member
theres no way a deadlifter would win. if say
dl guy dl 650 and bench 250
and
bench guy dl 400 and bench 500
and say they both weigh the same
id put my money on the bench guy because yeah the deadlift guy has a stronger base but i think its not so much about having a strong base but having a heavy one and i think, benching more will help with punching more ,than dling more will help with kicking and stomping
Anabolic Member
BENCH. One punch in the face from someone benching 400 lbs will hurt.
The only thing a deader can do is take him to the ground.
Since this has nothing to do with wrestling skills I think that is the limit of the deader.
The bencher will just push him off then slug him again.
Easy...deadlifter!
Take a look at any pro boxer/MA guy. Do you see the friggin traps and lats? How about the thighs?
Now take a look at the chest. A big chest slows down the punch. A powerful punch comes from the trunk, not the tit. The thick traps and neck help stabilize the neck...resulting in a less violent head snap upon receiving a punch...less chance of concusion..."stronger jaw."
Deads give thickness to the back, traps, and trunk.
Bench gives thickness to the tri's and pecs...slow punch.
Speed = power
Last edited by Swellin; 12-17-2003 at 09:12 PM.
Associate Member
Good point bermich, b4 that I would have said deader for sure. But anyway the REAL battle would be between a deader and squatter!
Senior Member
deadlifter
Senior Member
Actually power=speed+strength.
A squat is the best test of strength, and since the DL and squat are very similar, I would take the DLer over the bencher.
Anabolic Member
Swellin has a good point.
I am up in the air on this now.
I can bring up instances watching my brother get in fights and one hit would leave anyone out cold. He never did deads. Just solid benching. Everyone said his punches hurt even playin.
Traps and lats are all pulling motion except military. Benching all push. Push the guy away with force. If you wanna wrestler and pull him towards you then go with deads.
How are we gonna settle this?
Who here benches the most and favorably main exercise and who here mainly does dead lifts and lats?
We will put you two together in a fight.
Member
oh i wanna ref!
Member
I think that whether you are stronger in one lift versus another has nothing to do with who would win in a fight. Who would win? The more aggressive one would!
Rosie Member
Well then i hafto say a weightlifter would own a powerlifter! They have faster hands then a boxer and let me tell you one punch from a guy that can jerk 200kg´s (440lbs) will put you out cold for atleast 15 minutes.
Banned
just a thought, but if the bencher throws a punch the connects...I would say the deader goes down, hoss kinda pointed it out. you incorporate your tris quite a bit in bench.
But, imo, I would say who ever connected first!
Retired Vet
WOW. Another fight thread.. Where's my mate Chicomahoco (Or however you spell that phucking name).
Ok, ok are we assuming these two guys are experienced fighters already?. I doubt it, because most 99.9% of fighters I know will train in both Bench and Deads. I don't know one fighter who neglects either. Of course there's the other option as bdtr know...
A finger in the ass, in the eye and a kick in the nuts are pretty effective, lol....
You left out the GSW to the head.
Respected Member
OMG, this thread can't be for real? One rep max lifts got sweet FA to do with fighting. Who would be only a bencher or a deadlifter? Like many above have already said, most trainers do both. Weight training is simply a means of gaining stregth and power.
I feel obliged to mention the above technique series Bouncer pointed out only works on the second Tuesday of every other month......so use with caution.A finger in the ass, in the eye and a kick in the nuts are pretty effective, lol....
Associate Member
gene rylchek vs bolton
who will win??:spudnikli
VET
My personal opinion would be the dead lifter... just an opinion of course... but when when I learned to hit properly, most of the energy came from the legs and trunk.
Of course there is more than one way to skin a cat...
Red
Quadzilla
[QUOTE=chicamahomico]OMG, this thread can't be for real? One rep max lifts got sweet FA to do with fighting. Who would be only a bencher or a deadlifter? Like many above have already said, most trainers do both. Weight training is simply a means of gaining stregth and power.
who would only just bench...hehe have you been to the gym lately?
and I wanna stomp someone and see if the squat theroy is true...
Respected Member
Cmon big ol, smarten up!! Those guys do bicep curls to ya know.....who would only just bench...
and I wanna stomp someone and see if the squat theroy is true...
Retired
600+ dead for reps
500 bench for 1
VET
The guy with the chainsaw will win... doesn't matter how much he benches or deadlifts...
Red
Respected Member
I would happily get on the mat with any untrained fighter, I don't care if he can bench press a car. Or deadlift one.
<--- I've been waiting forever to use this one!
Senior Member
Bottom line it is a well rounded person who will win, but another good point is if u cant fight, u cant fight and no matter how strong u are ur not goin to win... But lets make this more interesting...
Deadlifter
Bencher
OR
Squater
Which will win that battle?
And to make this more realistic u can combine the total amount of 10 pnts on all three...
I go
3 bench
3 deahlifts
4 squats...
Def the best combo if u ask me......
Anabolic Member
Deads by far. Deadlifts involve more neurons, which would incorperate more muscles and stimulation. Yeah, it's true the bench would be able to push the Deader off of him once they're on the floor, but if the Deader gets a hold of the somma bitch, it's over.
Senior Member
deadlifts for sure
There are currently 1 users browsing this thread. (0 members and 1 guests)
Posting Permissions
Reply With Quote