Originally Posted by SwoleCat
Not so. I've seen this happen many times............
The one who ate more in the off-season also has to diet longer and harder to rid himself of all the excess fat, thus risking the loss of muscle that much more. The one who make more solid/permanent/lean mass gains doesn't have to diet that much or long at all, and finds it very easy to strip what little fat he has accrued.
As long as both are getting stronger and attaining lean muscle tissue (which is the focus of bulking up, it's not to get FAT), then I see no reason why you'd throw caution to the wind and eat whatever you wish only to make it that much harder on yourself later.
~SC~