
Originally Posted by
jfalco
It is common to cut by eating at maintainance and increasing cardio. I guess the increase in cardio actually increases your maintainance and essentially you are eating below maintainance if you do this, so I see what you are saying. Of course, by definition you won't loose weight if you are eating at maintainance, but most people don't think of it this way.
I don't know anything about the OP's current stats and goals, which is why I asked. I said for me, if I calculated my maintainance cals and then ate 500 less a day, I would be very tired and weak. I also need to eat about 700 cals above my calculated maintainance to gain a pound a week. If I eat at my maintainance, my weight stays very steady, so I think I have it right.
Sure we all know that the body needs about 3500 kcal to gain 1 pound. I'm not sure this translates directly to weight loss. Even if it does, how much of that pound do you want to be muscle. Personally I want it to be as close to zero as possible and for me, if I ate this little, I would loose more muscle than fat. The goal of cutting is fat loss not weight loss. We're all diffenent. I understand how diet affect my own body pretty well, but I can't say that what works for me or doesn't work for me will be the same for someone else.