
Originally Posted by
frodo89
1. Above you stated "You have to count your calories. Its the most important thing about your diet. If its results you are looking for, you need to get down to the science of your goals." You have to have a basis for this 'calorie counting'. We already know what his goal is. He wants to bulk. So that would be the basis of the caloric plan.
1.1. Essentially there would be no point in calculating your calories if you did not have a TDEE calculated which involves your BMR, which also involves some estimation of bf composition. I think here you meant counting your calories, so based on this you are some what correct. But if you knew how many calories you are taking in now and we figured out your diet from your TDEE then we can compare and make the changes accordingly
2. I never suggested impliedly or expressly that knowing your body fat is the core to making a sound diet, what I suggested was that he should find out his bf percentage, find out what his TDEE is and therefore make a diet that revolves around his TDEE so that he can maintain, lean bulk, whatever his goals may be. This is because I believe you should use your TDEE as a basis for your diet. Although it may not be fundamental on it's own, when combined to the use of a TDEE it becomes necessary for making your diet (1 and 2 refer to my argument).Knowing your body fat percentage is the first step in figuring out your lean mass which is what your TDEE is based on along with your daily activity level. Your diet is not based on body fat but body composition. But if you look at my first and second posts I ask him what all of these things are. I ask him what his macros are in his diet, what his tdee is and what his body comp is. If he doesnt know what the last 2 were, one would be figured out by the other.
3. I have read your posts, quite frankly I have learned a lot from you so if this is wrong like is said tell me I like learning about nutrition, it's become a hobby of mine.For the most part you have the right info but you are interpreting it slightly wrong. Hopefully I clarified whatever you were unclear on.