
Originally Posted by
CSAR
According to the October 2006 issue of M&F (Japan), Ronnie is listed at 180cm/133.8kg (5'9"/295lbs.) while Jay is listed at 175cm/270kg (5'7"/270lbs.).
Nark...A 25 pound difference is NOT "about the same weight," regardless of a 2 inch height difference (which IMO makes Ronnie look more massive than Jay).
No doubt that Ronnie looks denser...he's got 9 years of age/experience/muscle maturity over Jay. I agree that Jay's torso muscles tend to flatten out too.
Ronnie's got a big muscle separation in his linea alba, which makes it look like the "Alien" embryo is about to explode out of his gut. Plus he's been known to show up with gyno.
Is Ronnie more massive than Jay? YES! Does he look denser? YES! Is he favored to win? YES!
HOWEVER...IMO...Ronnie's just not aesthetically pleasing to look at. Ronnie is built like a Humvee. Jay is much more aesthetic, along with having excellent size and condition. Jay's built like a Ferrari.
Like I said before, it's near impossible to unseat a reigning Mr. O. Although Ronnie "just has to show up" to collect his Sandow, I hoping Jay wins.
Very good thread with nice arguments made on both sides, BTW.