
Originally Posted by
jay94
Well you are right that it's just personal preference, but for me fulfilling a small sugar craving tends to lead to a much bigger one, so I just avoid them as much as possible except for some fruits that are rich in fiber because those fill me up like I said. But again, that's just me and there might not be much science behind that. However, correct me if I'm mistaken but, soft drinks and processed food products like candy DO contain a lot of fructose and are a big part of a lot of people's diet, the latter which I believe to be one of the many reasons behind the complex issue that is the obesity epidemic. Is fructose to blame though? Or is it something else in those products? I don't know, that's why I've been looking at research, because I know better than to rely on bro science.
Like you said, eating one cookie means nothing in the grand scheme of things, but what I've noticed is that these people tend to eat not just one cookie, but 10 or more. Maybe not when they're out in the world and you see them, but in the tranquility of their home when they're bored and no one is looking at them, they do. Again, that is generalization at its finest, but it's definitely something I've seen and heard of. To me, there is a reason for everything: there is a reason why people are eating 10 cookies and not just one, or an entire bag of chips instead of just a few chips. There is also a reason why they are eating chips and cookies and not fruits and vegetables. To me, you have three options when it comes to weight loss: 1. you count calories; 2. you generally eat things that are high in dietary fiber and low in calories; 3. you do both, that is the best option. However, most people that I've tried to help lose weight obviously didn't wanna count calories, so I've tried to get them to put down the cookie jar and the bag of chips, but a lot of people fail to do this even though they seem to be motivated to do so to a certain extent, and I've been trying really hard to figure out why. Also, this is also merely anecdotal evidence, but I've noticed that a lot of people seem to feel depressed or sad when they stop eating simple carbs in large amounts, which makes it really likely that they won't be able to do it for long, and that's another thing for which I've been trying hard to find a reason. That's why it really made me enthusiast when I initially came across Dr. Lustig's work.
But I haven't just been looking at Dr. Lustig's work. I've also been looking at the relationship between food, appetite and various hormones, like insulin, cortisol, ghrelin and leptin. And I've also been looking at gut microbiota and how some gut microbes can 'hijack' the track between the gut and the brain in order to make the latter crave their preferred nutrients. In all cases, thank you for making me realize how flawed Lustig's work actually was. I guess that, just like him, I was caught up in my own biases. Finding a solution to the obesity epidemic is one of my lifetime goals and I'll keep looking.