...IMO, this line of thinking is a bigger problem than dog fighting.
NO. They are NOT BETTER. They are lesser creatures than "man". We are ABOVE them on the food chain. We OWN them... we control what/when/if they eat. We decide when they should breed, and when we should put them to death. As much as we love them, and accept selected ones as members of our family.... In REALITY, they are still JUST dogs.
While all of the touchy feely stuff you said is true (about their unconditional love and loyalty), it still does not make their lives EQUAL to the live of a human being. ANY human being.
My wife and I run a small Pit Bull rescue league (we have for the last eight years). I would bet anything I own, that we have sacrificed more of our time, energy, and MONEY for the good of the breed, than any of the other people in this thread COMBINED. I have spent my entire life (and will spend the rest of my life) fighting for the well being of these dogs. That said; I would sacrifice the lives of 1000 dogs if I knew it would save the life of ONE human being.
That’s not to say I condone dog fighting, or condone inhumane treatment of animals, just that I consider human life more valuable. (I’m sure being human, probably has something to do with that!

)
Now don’t get me wrong... I LOVE MY DOGS. But all the theoretical and spiritual mumbo-jumbo really isn’t relevant to this discussion IMO.
As far as you people who think these dogs were "Forced" to fight... step back and think really hard about that.
If you race dogs as a hobby, and $$ is not an option, are you going to buy your brood stock from a family of dogs who are known for producing sub-par racing dogs?? No. You are going to buy top of the line quality dogs, from a winning bloodline. You will not have to TRAIN the dogs to chase a rabbit. They will know to do it instinctually.
Same goes for "top of the line quality" fighting dogs. They do not have to be TAUGHT to fight. They are born with the instinct to do it. (This shouldn’t be confused with HUMAN AGRESSION which most TRUE fighting dogs are NOT born with.) If you have ever seen a litter of fighting dog puppies, you would notice that from the time they can walk and play, they are ALREADY going at it!! I have seen litters of puppies who would kill one another by 9 weeks old. Literally.
Listen guys...
I LOVE my dogs (probably more than most). The closest friend I ever knew in my life was a dog. If anyone were to hurt my dogs (without reason), I would most likely try to hurt them in return.
HOWEVER, I just can not equate a dog’s life, to that of a human being. It just seems silly to me. Maybe im just not wired to be as sensitive as others... who knows!?
But if you all REALLY want to help out… donate $$ to “NO KILL” shelters; particularly those which rescue APBT’s (American Pit Bull Terriers), and not PETA or HSUS. If you can’t find any, email me, and I will send you a list of them.
Just PLEASE... stop being "Sheeple". Nothing good ever comes from a Mob Mentality. Bashing Vick does NOTHING to help the cause which you all
seem to be so passionate about. Stop whining and dreaming up rediculously harsh punishments, and SUPPORT the folks who have the best interest of these dogs in mind. I assure you, PETA and HSUS DO NOT. They KILL more (adoptable) Pit Bulls every year (which are unfairly deemed "Vicious") than ANYONE.