
Originally Posted by
thisAngelBites
Disagree with this. You will definitely find physicians online (and IRL) who think adrenal fatigue is nonsense. Those physicians believe that you either have Addison's disease (very rare - where your adrenals produce significantly less steroid than what is compatible with life) or Cushing's disease (where your adrenals produce far too much steroid) and that any place between these (extremely large) reference ranges is normal.
So yes, adrenal fatigue is not a legitimate diagnosis, as far as many practitioners are concerned, but this has no bearing whatsoever on whether it is true that a condition exists whereby the adrenals are not making the optimum amount of cortisol, but are neither making a sufficiently small amount in order to be considered to be indicative of Addison's.
This model of thinking relies on test scores to be the ultimate diagnostic tool. One score on a test, and you're fine, one point less, and you have a life-threatening disease. One result at one lab, and you're fine, another result at another and again, it's life threatening.
It's not a terribly nuanced way of thinking that finds a patient with very low normal test results, but not in Addisonian ranges, and assumes they are fine, ignoring the many symptoms of Addison's they are displaying, until they finally test with one point less, then it is proclaimed that they have a serious medical problem.
This way of thinking also denies the fact that for many, many illnesses and disease there are mild and severe forms, and in many cases, progression from mild to severe. For example, this way of thinking denies the experience of many men on this forum, whose testosterone levels may not be completely tanked. Many physicians (and people reading their thoughts on the web) would therefore would say that Low Testosterone is more Internet hearsay than a legitimate diagnosis. But there are people here who have had testosterone in the low end of the normal range, and were symptomatic of low testosterone, whose symptoms were, in fact, alleviated by the administration of testosterone.
This is the kind of thinking that underpins this Internet hearsay position, which I find decidedly unpersuasive.