Judge dismisses charges against top Signature pharmacy officials
Sarah Lundy | Sentinel Staff Writer
2:37 PM EDT, September 11, 2008
An Albany, New York judge dismissed charges against the top officials of Signature Compounding Pharmacy, an Orlando family-run business that once raked in $30 million a year.
The decision marks the end of a complex legal wrangling that began in February 2007 with the arrest of Chief Executive Officer Naomi Loomis; her husband and Chief Operating Officer Robert "Stan" Loomis; his brother and head compounding pharmacist Kenneth "Mike" Loomis; and business-development director Kirk Calvert.
Another employee, Tony Palladino, was added to an indictment in October.
New York prosecutors tried to paint Signature pharmacy as the center of an illicit steroids and Internet drug-distribution network.
Related links
2 fined, agree to help Signature probe
Investigators accused the pharmacy of filling prescriptions issued by doctors who never examined the patients in person.
Judge Stephen Herrick wrote in his decision that the case was plagued with "extensive delays" due to the prosecutors presenting the case four different times to two grand juries.
"The court finds that the amorphous quality of the evolving indictments, coupled with the cursory and inadequate instructions in the fourth presentment have impaired the integrity of the grand jury proceedings to such a degree that a dismissal is warranted," he wrote in the 7-page ruling.
And, he wrote that he state can not present the case again -- therefore, ending the criminal process. Signature's Orlando attorney Amy Tingley said her clients were elated when she notified them this morning.
"This has been 20 months of stress and pressure," she said. "They are looking forward to picking up the pieces."
The stream of allegations -- many leaked out of the office of Albany County, N.Y. district Attorney David Soares -- damaged the businesses' reputation and attracted national media.
Signature officials continued to argue that like other pharmacies, it received prescriptions from doctors who sought valid medication for patients in need.
"Signature pharmacy is still in business," Tingley said. "Although the Albany district attorney stopped at nothing to try to hurt its reputation."