Arnold
Steven Seagal
New Member
The other day i was in a eternal discussion with three friends ... the discussion was about who would win in a fight Arnold or Steven (both in his best shape)
I said Arnold, but my friends keep insisting that Steven would win (because the aikido thing) ... what do you say ?
Last edited by EmilianoH; 01-10-2009 at 06:37 AM.
New Member
i would probably say stevey , it doesn't matter how big you get , you start messing with any of these ****ers who do self defence sports and they will take you out big time , i work with a few lads who do boxing , martial arts and that and have never lifted a weight in there lifes and when it kicked off big style they have dropped everybody on there arses before we've had a chance to get them outside
Productive Member
My heart says arnie as he's huge. But the security manager in work doesn't like anything special but he will rip your head off I've seen him fight and he just drops people not a bother.
Cycle King/AR-Hall of Famer/RETIRED
Size has nothing to do with fighting and Seagal is also like 6.4.
I'm cant believe this was a real discussion. I dont see how it could have lasted long.
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=herSynqVN3M
Arnie would get his ass beat and handed to him 10 different ways.
AR's Supplement Guru
Size has nothing to do with it. Seagal all the way.
Knowledgeable Member
Seagle all the way.
Arnie is a big cvnt, but Seagle is trained in knowing how to hurt someone.
Productive Member
All depends how the fight would go,
You can never put someone out of a fight no matter who they are against because there isn't rules or a set style. Who to say arnie wouldn't slam a r/hook into his head or ribs and drop Seagal.
Its like saying someone who has never had a fight would get there ass wooped by someone who does kick boxing. Yet the kick boxer slips when attempting a kick and the other lad gets on top.
If it was to a set fight style then you can question ability and possible winner. Ive been boxing since i was a kid and ive heard loads of street fights go ahead where someone can do this or that yet it never plans out as expected.
Anyway it would be a good fightand id defiantly pay per view it
Senior Member
segal most lily but if arnie got a hold of him...
New Member
yeah i would say the same mate but i see small guys go up against monsters every night and do them some real serious damage and literally have to pull them off to stop them doing permanant damage , i work with a few pro fighters and theres some only 11 or 12 stone wet and when they hit they ****ing make sure they are going to one place and one place only , taken out of the game all togetherOriginally Posted by xo3et
All depends how the fight would go,
You can never put someone out of a fight no matter who they are against because there isn't rules or a set style. Who to say arnie wouldn't slam a r/hook into his head or ribs and drop Seagal.
Its like saying someone who has never had a fight would get there ass wooped by someone who does kick boxing. Yet the kick boxer slips when attempting a kick and the other lad gets on top.
If it was to a set fight style then you can question ability and possible winner. Ive been boxing since i was a kid and ive heard loads of street fights go ahead where someone can do this or that yet it never plans out as expected.
Anyway it would be a good fight
Senior Member
so if size has nothing to do with a fight you would rather fight someone that is 250 and in shape than someone thats 150. but i do see what you saying
Cycle King/AR-Hall of Famer/RETIRED
That is like comparing a ferrari vs VW bug.All depends how the fight would go,
You can never put someone out of a fight no matter who they are against because there isn't rules or a set style. Who to say arnie wouldn't slam a r/hook into his head or ribs and drop Seagal.
Its like saying someone who has never had a fight would get there ass wooped by someone who does kick boxing. Yet the kick boxer slips when attempting a kick and the other lad gets on top.
If it was to a set fight style then you can question ability and possible winner. Ive been boxing since i was a kid and ive heard loads of street fights go ahead where someone can do this or that yet it never plans out as expected.
Anyway it would be a good fight
Yes, you can not rule our the bug if the ferrari blows his engine. But lets face it the chances of that are slim to none. And being both in there prime and new i dont think the VW has very good odds.
Productive Member
I understand what your saying dude. But fighting has such a large amount of options which can be taken its just too hard to say, especially when such a large powerful person is involved.
I'm just one of them people who never rule anything out until i see it happen
Anabolic Member
Seagal ... end of story.
AR's Hot British Pimp Daddy ~HOF~
Seagal to win...
Associate Member
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gejRc...eature=related
this one is better when he was younger Take sensei Steven Seagal
Associate Member
Veni, Vedi, Vici.
Body builders are not fighters and can't fight, too stiff to fight or move. Just nice to look at
Its like a size E or F boobs, too much but hey its fun to look at them.
Knowledgeable Member
I am by no means saying that Arnold would have beat up segal, but most of that stuff segal is doin in that video is like a dance.... I have seen and been in many,many fights and I have never seen dudes running and throwing them selves at someone like that. that is just plain silly. that MA originated from some real practical stuff, but majority of the time it won't shake down like that.
to all who throw a blanket stereotype that a bodybuilder can't fight are crazy. Franko Columbo use to box and I am sure his added size helped him a lot and in that pumping iron video, he wasn't some slow galoof... there are many slow akward bodybuilders and i am sure there are many rough tough ones that have fought a lot and got into the sport. you either got it in you or you don't.... when your light you fight, but when you get heavier it is just to your advantage... besides with guns, knives and intellect fighting with fists alone won't get you very far anyway.
these hypotheticals are fun as hell, but they are also pointless as hell...btw, I take arnold, not because i think he would win, but because segal is way to arrogant and Arnolds movies were ten times better....
Senior Member
Cycle King/AR-Hall of Famer/RETIRED
lolI am by no means saying that Arnold would have beat up segal, but most of that stuff segal is doin in that video is like a dance.... I have seen and been in many,many fights and I have never seen dudes running and throwing them selves at someone like that. that is just plain silly. that MA originated from some real practical stuff, but majority of the time it won't shake down like that.
to all who throw a blanket stereotype that a bodybuilder can't fight are crazy. Franko Columbo use to box and I am sure his added size helped him a lot and in that pumping iron video, he wasn't some slow galoof... there are many slow akward bodybuilders and i am sure there are many rough tough ones that have fought a lot and got into the sport. you either got it in you or you don't.... when your light you fight, but when you get heavier it is just to your advantage... besides with guns, knives and intellect fighting with fists alone won't get you very far anyway.
these hypotheticals are fun as hell, but they are also pointless as hell...btw, I take arnold, not because i think he would win, but because segal is way to arrogant and Arnolds movies were ten times better....
All the great fighters move like there dancing because there so fluent at the moves. If you look at Bruce Lee and Chuck they do the same thing. They also know how to use there components body eight agents them.
Guys keep saying the diff. Segals latter them and and was like 225 pounds. Yes Arnold had more muscle but still Sugal is not a small dude.
"T-MOS WILL LIVE THROUGH US FOREVER"
Segal all the way
CHEMICALLY ENGINEERED
x2. This whole thing is like comparing apples to oranges.
Fedor would crush Cutler
On a side note, I couldn't stop laughing at the video lol
Snook~ AR Lounge Monitor
Arnold has moves to you know ....
Anabolic Member
Size and strength is very important in fights.
We have weight classes for a reason boys.
Associate Member
125 pound dude or girl breaks a bottle over your head and then sticks the broken bottle up your throat, I dont think its going to matter how much you weigh!!!!!
u got knocked the fugg out
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=rjqm0EwT4Gs
Retired MONITOR
I'm not going to dignify this pole with a vote. Arnie was not a fighter! All show no go. Segal trained fighter. Arnold is numero uno!
physical pain is temporary. It may last a minute, or an hour, or a day, or a year, but eventually it will subside... The pain of quiting will lasts forever!!
arnold
here is why
http://au.youtube.com/watch?v=bxb0PCBV0vk - must watch akido video, this akido master gets whooped - badly
here what will matter arnei in his best shape wouldnt be in fight shape, cardio for fighting is in every muscle and it is like some super human factory buffering latic acid, fighters are a sick bread... fighting endurance is the exact opposite of body building (at least it feels like it).
segal, would have the edge if he could stay away from the terminator, and just get past the kindergardtner cop with shots to the kill zones
but, arnie on roid rage at the level he was juicing - seriously if he got in close to S.S. arnie might rip him in half....
Senior Member
hahah go arnie lolArnold has moves to you know ....
Have You Picked a Fight Lately?
Arnold killed the predator.
Arnold hands down.
Senior Member
Remember that time Arnold promised to kill Steven Seagal last?
He lied.
Senior Member
Haha, I also like that this is Seagal in "his best shape"...
Knowledgeable Member
steven seagal would win... one simple reason chuck norris cut off his pony tail and it grew into gteven seagal... chuck wouldwin easily and seagal is 2nd to him (due to the pony tail , kinda like that bible dude)
Associate Member
not happy to say this but steven would wipe the floor with arnold
Associate Member
I say Arnie. He has real endurance. I dont know about Seagal's cardio, but I know Arnold was no slouch.
Most of all, I just dont buy the martial art Steve is doing (I dont want to misspell). It looks semi WWF. People running and flipping. Like someone said above, that isnt how fights go down.
I also havent seen too many shots of Steve without his shirt, but he usually has some nice boobies.
-------------------
edit:
After searching for shirtless pics of STeve to no avail, I discovered he sells blues cds and energy drinks. I think Arnold has already won the 'battle' of life.
Last edited by Diary of a Mad-man; 01-12-2009 at 04:48 PM.
Anabolic Member
There was a thing on TV a couple years ago where different celebrities compete in different sports and contests and what-not, and Steven Segal lost a foot-race (Like the 100 meter or something like that) to Andy Griffith!! The dude's like 100 years old!! I lost my faith in Stevie right then and there.
Anabolic Member
Arnold wins on not being a miserable hack faggot
"T-MOS WILL LIVE THROUGH US FOREVER"
I felt bad for going against arnold so I am put it down for him now.
There are currently 1 users browsing this thread. (0 members and 1 guests)
Posting Permissions
Reply With Quote
