i keep hearing different answers on this

i am currently under the impression that more protein is needed when cutting because of the lack of carbs

and less pro when bulking due to high Carbs

but why do i keep hearing different answers - i have just read the "how to bulk thread"

and it advocates 56% protein 33% carbs and 11%

i'm sorry but this sounds more like a cutting diet to me

i would personally think pro 40%, Carb 40% and Fat 20% would be far more appropriate

anyone agree/disagree?