Fedor VS Roger

[J-Dogg]

dude, its ok the rest, but couture??? 2 wins in 8 years? and 2 years ago, no matter if he was facing hulk and manage to beat him, he cannot be top 10, hell not even top 15. And im sorry, but he didnt find the way to beat Brock, nor to beat Nog, and frankly, if GG hadnt accidentally broken his nose,I really doubt he would've beat him... , in fact, he didnt find the way to beat a LOT of his oponents... Randy is a great guy, great sportsman, captain america and all you want, but he certanly isnt a top 10 HW.

Ya, I do see your point with Randy.

I guess I still give him credit, because he "retired" a top 5 HW and as the HW champ in the UFC.

He came out of retirment and got beat by Brock and Nog. I don't think Randy can or should be able to beat Fedor, Brock or Nog though. He came out of retirment and got beat by the number 2 and 3/4 HWs in the world. After putting Fedor at number 1, would you agree (in no order) that Barnett, Brock, Nog and Mir would probably round out the top 5?

I would still place him right around the area I would Tim and AA though. If he was given the fights AA was, his win/loss would probably be the same as AA has been for the past 2 years.

I can't justify just dropping Randy off the top 10 for loosing to people that are in the top 3.

[roid_rage]

Ya, I do see your point with Randy.

I guess I still give him credit, because he "retired" a top 5 HW and as the HW champ in the UFC.

He came out of retirment and got beat by Brock and Nog. I don't think Randy can or should be able to beat Fedor, Brock or Nog though. He came out of retirment and got beat by the number 2 and 3/4 HWs in the world. After putting Fedor at number 1, would you agree (in no order) that Barnett, Brock, Nog and Mir would probably round out the top 5?

I would still place him right around the area I would Tim and AA though. If he was given the fights AA was, his win/loss would probably be the same as AA has been for the past 2 years.

I can't justify just dropping Randy off the top 10 for loosing to people that are in the top 3.

I agree on that, dont know about mir, but I guess he should be right there. I think JDS deseves it right now more than Mir, and I do think JDS will beat the living crap out of him...

And about Randy, well, you shouldnt justify him in the top 10 for 2 wins in 8 and 2 years ago either dont you think?...