Quote Originally Posted by J-Dogg View Post
Ya, I do see your point with Randy.

I guess I still give him credit, because he "retired" a top 5 HW and as the HW champ in the UFC.

He came out of retirment and got beat by Brock and Nog. I don't think Randy can or should be able to beat Fedor, Brock or Nog though. He came out of retirment and got beat by the number 2 and 3/4 HWs in the world. After putting Fedor at number 1, would you agree (in no order) that Barnett, Brock, Nog and Mir would probably round out the top 5?

I would still place him right around the area I would Tim and AA though. If he was given the fights AA was, his win/loss would probably be the same as AA has been for the past 2 years.

I can't justify just dropping Randy off the top 10 for loosing to people that are in the top 3.

I agree on that, dont know about mir, but I guess he should be right there. I think JDS deseves it right now more than Mir, and I do think JDS will beat the living crap out of him...

And about Randy, well, you shouldnt justify him in the top 10 for 2 wins in 8 and 2 years ago either dont you think?...