
Originally Posted by
thegodfather
I have a great understanding of the meetings, I would recommend them as a complement to mainstream medical science such as medication, replacement therapy or antagonists, cognitive behavioral therapy, etc. By the way, when I said serious medical issues, I was also referring to those afflicted with substance dependence ('addiction' is not a recognized disease in the DSM, but substance dependence is, and I refuse to use words created by an industry for the purpose of profiting from peoples pain and suffering). I believe that any organization that ONLY advocates AA/NA as a means of recovery are committing malpractice, and the fact that they will not consider other multi-modal methods of treatment IS malpractice, it is DANGEROUS, and it CAUSES DEATHS in this country. The statistics do not lie, and a SUB 8% recovery rate is nothing to be proud of, when there are proven, scientifically sound, medicine based alternatives which DO produce results and DO save peoples lives. If substance dependence is in fact a brain disease, then by definition a group of people in a room would not be capable of curing it. Just as a group of people in a room could not cure someone of diabetes or cancer. This is a MEDICAL ILLNESS with a MEDICAL SOLUTION, not a bunch of laymen's in a room peer pressuring one another and preaching total abstinence from all drugs. AA/NA works for a very very small percentage of patients, and I do not actually take issue with the group itself, they're great people. I mostly take issue with the 'rehabs' who ONLY preach abstinence based recovery, when the science PROVES that it most often ends in failure, relapse, and very often DEATH. In addition, I can't count how many patients have gone off their psych meds because some DOUHEBAG at an AA/NA meeting told them they aren't actually 'clean' if they take meds. That is a decision SOLELY up to the patient and his/her doctor, and ANYONE who gives ADVICE at a meeting that they stop taking those medications should be held criminally liable for giving medical advice without a license. That is the only way to stop dangerous and destructive advice from being given to extremely vulnerable people. The entire 'treatment' community as a whole is not based in science, at least those organizations who offer only an abstinence based/faith based recovery to patients, and it's appalling to me that the insurance companies actually pay these witch doctors to preach their unscientific and unsupported bullshit. Why does the average substance dependent person take 7 stints in rehab to abstain for at least 1 year? Because their programs do not work. The average cost for 7 - 30 day rehab stays? $210,000 US Dollars. Believe me, I can achieve far superior results with medicine, cognitive behavioral therapy, and an IOP.