Vaccines are always to generate immunity from viruses that can cause severe long term health impacts (like polio) or death (like most of the diseases we have vaccines for). Some viruses, like the common cold and cold sores (a type of herpes), have little to no complications and death except for extreme circumstances (like if the person has AIDS). Thus, there is no health, economic, or societal need for a vaccine for the common cold.
I am not sure what you mean by the "original SARS virus", but there are vaccines for several of the coronavirus-related illnesses. In some cases, the vaccines are not mass produces or distributes as there are no breakouts. We don't take all vaccines that we have available. Smallpox, for example, has been eradicated except for very isolated cases.
The SARS-CoV-2 vaccine was created "so quickly" due to a massive international effort by thousands of scientists, companies, and countries across the world. There was tremendous worldwide effort and funding put into developing a vaccine. Under "normal" circumstances the vaccines take much longer as they are not supported by so many people or funding.
Is it at least 94% effective? According to testing, yes.
Is it like the flu vaccine? Yes and no. Yes, in the sense that the patient will not see much difference in the administration of the vaccine or its side effects. And no, it is not generated using the same biotechnology. In fact, there are several SARS-CoV-2 vaccines created using a number of methodologies that are in the final stages right now across the world.
Seems like you answered that pretty well . Its still very strange to me a vaccine was created in less than a year. And the “testing” will have to be trusted based on individuals themselves i dont think it should be mandated or forced upon people to take this vaccine but I believe we are headed that way. Id like for more “testing” to be done. I am pro vaccine as both my children have received every vaccine that has been available. And i was referring to the sars virus of 2002 when i said original sars virus. Apparently this version is much more contagious.
I have quite a few that are shared by my wife and many of our friends if you don’t mind taking the time. And no, I am not trying to be confrontational or negative, but we have been underwhelmed with the information provided to date regarding the vaccine(s).
By successful, what is meant by that:
*Not dying?
*No hospitalization?
*if hospitalized, will ventilators be needed?
*No symptoms at all, mild symptoms or severe symptoms not requiring hospitalization?
* Break Down of those categories by age, gender & race.
Percentage of those that will get sick from the vaccine?
*How sick? Is there a chance of hospitalization or even death?
* If so, a breakdown of those possibilities per age, gender & race.
These are logical questions that should have some degree of knowledge in order to allow the individual to choose intelligently.
For what it’s worth, I am pro mask & pro social distancing & I support many if not all of the closures & the possibility of another lock down. But, as I said, the information that has been presented to date regarding the vaccines has been less than satisfactory.
You would be the very first person that I would have encountered on the front lines of this vaccine process & am really looking forward to your insight. Genuinely and sincerely thankful for your time.
So, for the vaccine that is 94% effective, that means 94% of people will achieve immunity and will therefore not be able to carry replicable virus levels in their bodies. The other 6% will not achieve immunity and will thus still be susceptible as we all are now, meaning of that 6%, IF they catch the virus, most will be asymptomatic and a small number will require treatment.
The important thing to remember is that the virus is caught from other people. If people take a vaccine that is 94% effective, that means 94% of people cannot transmit the virus AT ALL. thus, the chances of you catching it now go to WAY less than 6% considering that you have to be exposed to the virus from a person that is from that 6%, and that is <<6%. I hope this makes sense.
This is, in fact, the entire purpose of immunization - it protects everyone and can eventually eradicate the virus from the population, like smallpox and polio for many countries.
This is not a number I have offhand because it would need to be gleaned from the clinical trial data for each vaccine. But regardless, this number is WAY less than the number getting the virus now, and your chance of getting seriously ill from the vaccine is FAR less than the chances currently. That refers to the above discussion. THIS is what herd immunity is, not the nonsense they spout about everyone getting sick.
I greatly appreciate your response, thank you.
It was the effectiveness rate that we have seen conflicting articles on, and these are very recent articles. I have seen their version of success being not dying and another version of success of being not “severely” ill. As these studies have not been published or reviewed by medical journals, I thought you might have had greater access. If in fact the vaccine assures immunity (even if at below 90%, let alone 94%), I would say that that is a phenomenal number after such a short development time.
Regarding the herd immunity, couldn’t be in more agreement & have had far too many frustrating discussions with others in the previous months about that.
I would be very interested in those that could get sick or even die however. I think that fact alone would put a great many at better ease when deciding if they should take the vaccine. I personally will get sick when I get the flu vaccine & will no longer take it. That is my concern regarding this vaccine.
Thank you again.
Not really a question, but a reply where you stated the data hasn’t been gleaned yet.
Because Covid-19 has such a varied rate on different ages, you could see how the elderly, the healthcare workers, first responders are at a higher risk to Covid and would less likely worry about negative effects from the vaccine. Just as you said, you’re far more likely to be infected & subsequently ill from Covid, as compared to the vaccine. Thus the vaccine seems to be well worth any risks.
But, unlike the flu and other diseases that are far more serious in their symptoms for the younger population as compared to Covid, and where a vaccination is definitely warranted; Covid is different. There still is a back-lash and distrust of other vaccines by parents concerned about the [I]possibility[I] of autism. And if you are in your late teens or early twenties, what’s the likelihood you are going to be hospitalized or die from Covid? I can see how parents could be very hesitant about giving their child a vaccination to a disease that really isn’t that dangerous for their children. BUT, if you see a vaccine “rushed”, where other vaccines typically take years of study and development, I too might be concerned. What potential long term side effects might this vaccine possibly cause?
If I were to take the vaccine or give it to my children, I would want some definitive assurances that it is indeed safe.
Once again, not trying to be argumentative, but this is data that hasn’t been available to my knowledge. So regarding the general public being reluctant or concerned about being “forced” to vaccinate (which won’t happen), I can see their concern (unlike the reluctance of mask wearing, social distancing & large gatherings).
Do you have any data to back up this statement? I am genuinely interested in what should be obvious reasons!
I mean, they are not taking the vaccine for themselves but to not transmit the disease to other which is the fact for most people with almost any illness.
I think I answered this to Cuz above but maybe in a different manner. This is not rushed. This is how long it would take if you spend 10-100 times more money on something involving 1000 upon 1000 of more people working towards a single target. The compute bill, alone, for Running the models of this is about $500,000/week. No one spends that kind of money normally on a vaccine as vaccines, generally speaking, is not a money-making machine compared to other medicines.
You will never take a single vaccine if this is the requirement, it's that simple. The only one who could tell you this with 100% certainty would be God and I have not seen him making any vaccines lately.
If you have more targeted questions I'm happy to answer those but anymore wondering about safety, efficacy, and such I have already answered to the best of my ability and I think much can easily be extrapolated from that.
I’m sorry, you misunderstood me a bit and that is my fault.
I did ask and you stated the answer wasn’t gleaned from the clinical trial data. That’s a great answer and one that indicates why there is concern by those taking a vaccination that was truly developed quickly.
I am not debating or disputing you, your work, or your opinion or the value & purpose of vaccines in general. I am aware why vaccines should be taken as a moral and responsible act to help society. However the truth of the matter, for instance with a flu vaccine, it is generally taken for personal health concerns. Does a parent want their child want to get small pox or polio? No, of course not, thus the vaccine. When a student goes to college, they must be vaccinated for meningitis because nobody in their right mind wants meningitis. But of course, then you are also contributing to society. I’m sure you keep current, you certainly know of the back and forth regarding “anti-vaccine parents” not wanting to run the risk of autism for their kids.
Today’s society is somewhat less than altruistic, there is a personal risk vs. reward attitude. For instance mask wearing, a person would argue why should I be burdened with wearing a mask if all I am going to do is get something similar to the flu? Clearly that individual has little interest in helping others and limit the spread of Covid.
Now this same group of individuals are not asked to do something as simple and non-invasive as wearing a mask. You are asking them to inject themselves with something that has not been studied and researched for as long as other vaccines. What IF they can get sick because of the vaccine; I think it’s fair to ask what the chances are & to what severity. Information that you’ve already stated that you don’t know (that is not intended as a criticism, you simply don’t know).
Regarding the severity in different age groups, I am stating hospitalization and death rates provided by the CDC and how they steadily decrease as the ages get younger and younger.
Tell me, what will happen in the public schools if enough parents refuse to vaccinate their kids?
Simply stated, you think getting people to wear a mask was and STILL is difficult - good luck with vaccines, just my opinion.
I’m just making an observation, not debating with you. You’ve already answered my question and It was appreciated.
Edit: this is a heated topic. I am NOT arguing or debating you or anyone here. I know how contemptuous things get and DON’T want that! These are just my observations.
Last edited by wango; 12-05-2020 at 02:56 PM.
There are 3 loves in my life: my wife, my English mastiffs, and my weightlifting....Man, my wife gets really pissed when I get the 3 confused...
A minimum of 100 posts and 45 days membership required for source checks. Source checks are performed at my discretion.
...................
These are the people I was referring too...
Attachment 180302
Not looking to start a fight.
Just think you may thought I was attacking people here.
I thought my point was obvious but I think I failed to make it.
There is a subset of America that thinks wearing masks is Un-American.
That it is part of a vast conspiracy to rid them of their freedom...
and thus in not wearing a mask they are fighting for Freedom.
Didn't think you were attacking anyone at all. I do think that those you refer to are tired of the flip flopping being offerred by the top scientists and then the politicians with their do what i say not what i do actions that are so self-evident lately.
When it comes to images of unmased people just as many can be found of protesters / rioters / activists not wearing masks as well. But, being that 90% of the media has a left leaning bias they simply don't get the air time in the same manner, imho. But, hopefully the meds get cleared asap and people get innoculated and it begins a positive path forward.
I'm definitely up for taking the vaccine when available. I know some people are leery of it, but at my age the damage is done anyway. I'd make a good crash test....dummy/victim.
There are 3 loves in my life: my wife, my English mastiffs, and my weightlifting....Man, my wife gets really pissed when I get the 3 confused...
A minimum of 100 posts and 45 days membership required for source checks. Source checks are performed at my discretion.
I have painfully taken measures to make sure that I don't read or hear any news since this past summer. My grandmother always told me that a person that does not read is smarter than someone that only reads the news. With that in mind, my stance is coming from my knowledge of science and how a virus is spread. If masks, like a bandana, worked so well then why didn't it help with the Spanish Flu? Why not only wear surgical masks when working with other viruses like Ebola? It's simple, masks don't work on fighting a virus. A large study was done, which has been removed from NIH and other sites now showing that masks don't work fighting the flu (airborne viruses) with hospital workers.
Mask and gloves do not replace the human's natural immune system. I personally feel that most people should not listen to government "experts" but should follow ALL the science, not the cherry-picked sections. People die every year. We are all going to die of something. Get out and live your life and don't depend on any government to save you. And if our constitution clearly lays out what the role of the government is and taking away the liberties of citizens is not one of them.
My thoughts on the virus are like any virus, live a healthy lifestyle, eat correctly, be physically active, and have good personal hygiene should be all you need. And if you are sick, stay at home and don't be a dick. And if you get sick, go see a doctor as soon as possible.
I don't think when Polio was an issue in the US we wore masks. But from what I remember about Polio, you have only spread that virus in the first 7-10 days after symptoms. So if you were symptomatic, don't be a Dick and stay home until you see a doctor. But there is a vaccine coming out for covid, and everyone I talked to about it is not going to get it. Including my 80-year-old mother and father.
I am not an anti-vaccine person. I have already received my Flu shot and get at least one every year. But I have gotten the flu during a year I got the flu shot. Everyone I personally have talked to about the mask and the Covid all has not gotten a flu shot in the past several years. Less than 50% of the US gets this shot and we know the flu kills people.
In a few years, people will still be getting covid and/or the flu and not getting the vaccine. People will be more complacent with the risk of covid just like the flu and not get a shot.
I love this forum! One of the few places where people can have a different opinion and disagree without being disagreeable. I do truly hope that everyone is in good health.
DLP, regarding the 1918 flu, it happened during World War 1. Troops tightly confined in barracks at training. Soldiers transferring to different training facilities and spreading it to those communities. Then overseas, once again spreading it to various regions. It’s a small miracle more didn’t die. We learned our lesson with that, which is why nobody traveled or flew during Thanksgiving and will do the same for Christmas.
Just a nice, simply written article on efficacy vs. efficiency of vaccine trials.
https://www.nytimes.com/2020/11/20/h...effective.html
Your logic is flawed and wearing a mask helps to not spread the virus. That is not an opinion that is a fact! You are welcome to post any actual peer-reviewed content that proves your point and I will, with genuine interest, read it. To think that COVID-19 is somehow a "special" virus that escapes masks is not true. Anything that exits the mouth or nose is transmitted around and can, more or less, be intercepted, alternatively filtered.
This is a great read to better understand how things are moving so quickly on the vaccine front for which we should all be thankful!
We Had the Vaccine the Whole TimeYou may be surprised to learn that of the trio of long-awaited coronavirus vaccines, the most promising, Moderna’s mRNA-1273, which reported a 94.5 percent efficacy rate on November 16, had been designed by January 13. This was just two days after the genetic sequence had been made public in an act of scientific and humanitarian generosity that resulted in China’s Yong-Zhen Zhang’s being temporarily forced out of his lab. In Massachusetts, the Moderna vaccine design took all of one weekend. It was completed before China had even acknowledged that the disease could be transmitted from human to human, more than a week before the first confirmed coronavirus case in the United States. By the time the first American death was announced a month later, the vaccine had already been manufactured and shipped to the National Institutes of Health for the beginning of its Phase I clinical trial. This is — as the country and the world are rightly celebrating — the fastest timeline of development in the history of vaccines. It also means that for the entire span of the pandemic in this country, which has already killed more than 250,000 Americans, we had the tools we needed to prevent it.
You hit the nail on the head. MY OPINION! I see a rush to put out studies that show how the mask "stops the spread of COVID 19", so there is bias IMO on all these studies. Medical personal used to use universal precautions but in 1996, the CDC expanded the concept and changed the term to standard precautions, which integrated and expanded the elements of universal precautions to include contact with all body fluids (except sweat), regardless of whether blood is present. But before COVID 19 you didn't hear anyone running around telling people to wear a mask for the SARS or MERS (COVID), or even for the flu (H1N1). Not even if you were going to visit anyone in a nursing home or a hospital.
I never said that COVID 19 was a special virus. IMO, it has been blown way out of proportion by the media and the politicians. Next time you go to the grocery store or gas station look around at all the masks on the ground and tell me that is not a biohazard. There is also a lot of unintended consequences from mandating people to wear PPE and not educating them on the proper disposal of PPE.
So my stance, although it is not popular, is you do you and I do me. I wear a mask when I have to but that is it. I hate them, I cant understand what people are saying while wearing a mask, and I think they provide more of a placebo effect for the masses. But I also have stated, I have the antibodies for COVID so I have had it. This leads to an interesting segway, now we have people that have recovered from the virus or getting immunized from it. Do you still want everyone wearing a mask for the rest of your life or when will it be safe to not wear a mask anymore?
Why Most Published Research Findings Are False
https://journals.plos.org/plosmedici...l.pmed.0020124
The virus is much less deadly than SARS or MERS. MERS is around 30% death rate. However only 2 people died from it in the US back during the outbreak.
For whatever reason, COVID-19 spreads more rapidly. Even at the current 1-2% death rate, a lot of people are dying and a lot more would die if masks were not worn. Masks trap viruses in our spit, water molecules in our breath.
There is a reason red states are getting hit so hard now. A lot of people initially weren’t concerned because sparsely populated areas weren’t affected as much during the first wave. Now a lot more people are infected nationwide, so even rural areas are getting hit harder. Especially places where people are not wearing masks. Trump and Giuliani didn’t wear masks religiously and they both got it. Kamala and Biden do, and they didn’t get it. Couldn’t be more clear of a message, no matter what either side says.
I have friends my age that live all over the world and every one of them has a different feeling about it. I can't write or say anything that is going to change your mind. I don't want to debate different virus or whatever, I am just a firm believer in personal liberty and not being told to wear a mask. IMO they don't work, especially as a one size fits all fix. People don't wear or use them correctly from what I have seen. On 10/15/20 the CDC stated: "85% of COVID-19 patients report ‘always’ or ‘often’ wearing masks". IMO will get covid at some point, it's all about the individual's immune system's ability to handle it.
But think about this. Not all medical people can agree on treatments due to the politics of COVID. If you have a different view than what the government tells you to have then you are a horrible person or you get removed from social media or whatever they do on those sites. The one thing that every medical professional agrees on is obesity. Covid and obesity is the real conversation and not one is telling people to eat right and lose weight so if you do get Covid you have a better chance to live.
I mean everyone can do what they want, but I’m pretty sure almost everyone in the medical community agrees that masks help slow down the spread of viruses. They exist for a reason. Not everyone has to contract the virus if we get vaccines. I agree that the majority of the people infected that have passed from it have had pre-existing conditions, but still there have been some healthy people that have died as well. Part of the fear with this virus is that nobody knows how it’s going to affect them.
I’m glad I don’t have to be the one making up rules because there’s no way to make everyone happy. I just wear my mask when I’m in a store and keep to myself mostly. I don’t feel that this invades my personal freedom in any way, it’s just a common courtesy to protect our fellow people who might not be as safe as we are. I see little old ladies shoppin on alone at the grocery store and imagine how they must feel knowing they put themselves in danger doing regular shit. It has to suck. The mask on my face sucks but dying (even if it’s not me) sucks more.
Fascinating! You pulled one single word out of my entire paragraph and created your very own narrative by adding one word yourself. Do not think I have seen something that so clearly illustrates what the issue actually is. Hope you and the rest of your family stays safe during this difficult time. Good luck!
Well, I have way too much free time on my hands apparently
Vaccine < LoL, fuck that
Never had a flu vaccine either & have never tested positive when I got sick
This is why I made myself live the way that I have this year - no gym, no school for my son, we hardly ever go out - for now
I don’t know or care what political POS is up to what - but, I trust my home brew guy more than the “government” now
I have seen what effects this “virus” has on us up close - numerous times. . . So, I still choose to live the way that I do
I was talking to my DOT MD yesterday. He’s pro vaccine, but agrees on everything else I say - so, whatever
I’m still alive - for now
First thing I see when I get off the page - fuck all this, I’ll stick to my bathtub brew guy’s vaccine 1st
https://www.yahoo.com/news/australia...072111768.html
Last edited by < <Samson> >; 12-11-2020 at 06:15 AM.
Right,
Thought I’d speed a little holiday spirit
Vaccine
To each is own - I’ll stick to my eod home brew slams of sauce
That’s fine & all - I just don’t know when I’ll be mentally ready for my son to receive this make believe garbage - since they administer shit at school now - they did a flu shot without our knowledge last time
Gawd wtf happened to this country - it sure seems so different than how I first remember it from almost 30 years ago
Coughing gorillas at the San Diego zoo are Covid positive.
Gorilla’s blame Charger and his gym for lax mask wearing rules . . . . .
Last edited by wango; 01-11-2021 at 05:08 PM.
There are currently 1 users browsing this thread. (0 members and 1 guests)