Testing Amplify 02

[jimmyinkedup]

I am not going to take 10 GRAMS of sodium phosphate a day for 75 days for about a dozen reasons, none of which help your point. Who would eat TEN GRAMS of salt everyday on top of their normal diet? It is a retarded question. You cannot just arbitrarily select a ridiculous amount of a substance and claim that harm at one dosage bears some linear relevance at any dosage. A standard large pill contains about one third to a half a gram of ingredients. Those pills have a dozen ingredients. Even if I granted you that they contain 100mg each of sodium phosphate you would need to take 600 of them per day to reach the amount in the bowel prep.

You had to ask three times because it was a silly enough question I was going to let it slide. Let me ask you, would you eat 300 eggs in one sitting? Maybe your stomach would burst! Therefore why would you want to ingest this potentially deadly substance in any dosage?

You failed toaddress these points:
i reiterate:

this supp has this ingredient ...in an amount unknown to you ...but you assume its safe ...b/c of the # of caps. But it is associated with the aforementioned disorders....the demographic here is very likely to be taking other risk increasing compounds .Do you , as a doctor, really think its smart to defend this ingredient ....with unknown risk factors ...in a demographic likely to be using one or more substances known to increase these risks?
See for me its easy - its associated with the disorder ....its in a supp u take daily ...why take it? at any dose.


Where you go wrong is you try to argue opinions - ...you see i read info on an ingredient - i assessed it - i formed and stated an opinion - based on facts i read. Re read this thread. You then sarcastically question my knowledge of chemistry - which i ignore and ask for your input. You then proceed to explain why i deserve to be talked down to ..blah blah blah. I have my opinion - in my mind it is justified. Answer my above questions honestly and on some level we agree i believe - i cant imagine you saying yeah ill take it with an nsaid and /or'> tren. Or yeah its a good thing to take a supp with this ingredient and other potential associated risk factors(unknown to you). Or you know what maybe you think its fine ...and thats ok - but taking the thread to personal attacks etc ...you went there - its stupid - and YOUR peers (acutually not your peers - specialists - urologists , etc...) wrote the articles i read....the FDA - who we both know well - warned not only against high dosage but low dose long term use - "potential build up of phosphate crystals leading to possible renal failure. "

Why did you fail to address the above?
You claim its a salt and a phospahte blah blah blah - the body removes it all the time. OK so take 2 teaspoons of table salt in h20 daily in addition to your normal diet.....intelligent - no ...healthy -no.
I guess you know the kidney so well ALL the experts that wrote the articles and studies i cited are wrong. The FDA investigated / regulated OTC products containing this very ingredient for the dangers i mentioned..... and they must be wrong too.

Given all the above info - the studies - the fda findings -the risk with low dose long term usage (documented by the fda btw) you STILL want to argue this point. You must be right - they are all wrong...and then to boot you call me an idiot.

People can read and decide for themselves.
I wont take the supplement. Thats my opinion - you havent changed it.

Oh but wait that wasnt your goal anyway was it - you entered the thread spewing insults at me from the start.
Its easier to do that than to read the links i posted - acknowledge the truth in the bold statements above - and actually admit you dont know everything.
It's easier stating everyone else including urologists , specialists and the FDA are wrong ...and you ....a resident (no disrespect - just pointing itout for comparison purposes) are correct.
I find that hard to believe - even for you.