Thread: Ask the Exercise Scientist
-
01-12-2009, 10:50 AM #321
not sure if this is your field...maybe more of a ...i dunno who sports medicine q, but anyway still appreciate your opinion..
i do back extensions with a dumbell, currently 65 pounds, several sets of 10 - 12 reps. i've been doing that because deadlift and other lumbar spine intensive exercises make me nervous about hurting my L-spine.
you have opniion on that? is it safer for working the lower back than squats and deadlifts ?? still have to guard against lumbar curvature during the extension?
-
-
I usually do not go into full hyperextension when I do extension exercises. Just because when you go into hyperextension you are compressing the posterior structures of the spine. (posterior portion of the annulus of the disc, Facet joints..ect)
Generally for most lumbar spine injuries the actual mechanism of injury is when the spine is in flexion, at least as far as disc injuries are concerned.
As far as proper lifting is concerned the best thing to do no matter the exercise, is keeping the back in a neutral position. This is the best way to prevent injury. Keeping a neutral back most effectively spreads the force from lifting across all the structure more proportionally.
-
01-12-2009, 12:36 PM #324
yes. i try not to hyper extend. i will watch as i extend with the heavy dumbell ( from the inverted 'V' position), to make sure my flexion is all in the hips...
-
01-12-2009, 01:08 PM #325
for a while now i have been training a bodypart once a week.
EX.
MON - chest
TUES-bi
WED- shoulder
THURS- off
FRI- legs
SAT-tri
SUN-back
for whatever reason i have been making gains. i ssume this is a less then ideal way to train correct? it is just that my muscles have gotten used to high volume and i have to beat the hell out of them. what are your thoguts on training like this. also if i miss more the one day a week then it is 8 days between parts.
-
01-12-2009, 01:50 PM #326
k, i've got a couple questions, though they aren't related to exercise exactly
1) What is the best stage of ripeness to eat a banana for PWO, if i remember correctly when they are green they are almost all starch and as they oxidize they turn towards a higher concentration of sugar
2) Is there a difference in thermogenesis from drinking egg whites(egg beaters or offbrand) or heating them up in the microwave so they fluff up and then eating them?
3) Same question as above with regard to protein synthesis
btw, i figured out why i have been sleeping so late, though i'm not ruling out what you said, i'm going to run a mini experiment and see what becomes of it
basically i built the apartment i live in now and it is very well made and insulated, but i also built it to be completely dark when i want it to be and completely light when i want it to be by putting three large windows, with blackout curtains in them
the reason for this is that i have a projector which i use as my computer screen, tv, game screen, everything, but the image whites out if there is light and i have to turn up the lumenosity of bulb which burns it out faster
anyway, i always leave my windows covered, even at night, but last night i didn't, and i woke up at 10 with no alarm, there is a window in front of each of my beds so i think that the reason i have been sleeping in is that my body still thinks it's night at 2 in the afternoon because there no light
this theory is compounded by the fact that i used to wake up at the break of dawn to go to the gym, and the light from my windows probably was my wakeup, as i never set an alarm
what do you think?Last edited by Phate; 01-12-2009 at 01:55 PM.
-
If you have been making gains then I would stick with your plan. I actually train each body part only once a week. I have done this with great success. I use to train each body part 2 times a week and while I made good gains, I also experienced more aches and pains.
I actually prefer the once a week method with anyone who is trained. Novice exercisers you can generally get away with more than once a week per body part because gains in a untrained individual are almost entirely from nervous system adaptation and I like to take advantage of this quick learning curve if you will to maximize gains starting out.
For a trained individual though, I prefer once a week because it gives me less of a chance of the person becoming overtrained and allows for full and complete recovery in most instances between bouts of exercise.
-
-
01-12-2009, 03:54 PM #329
"Uncooked egg white protein loss can be as much as 25% of protein content vs about 5% for cooked eggs"
when you say cooked do you mean pasteurized, microwaved, heated in a skillet?
-
-
Hey MS
Do you think P90X would be good to get in hiking shape.
Obviously it doesn't have weighted pack stairmaster or anything, but as far as muscle endurance and whatnot, would P90X be of benefit to backpacking?
-
01-13-2009, 04:45 PM #332
By what action/pathway do SERM's improve Lipid Profile (HDL)?
By what action/pathway do AS (particularly Var) worsen lipid profile (LDL)?
By what action/pathway do AI's worsen lipid profile (LDL)?
This was raised today on my PT course and no one had any answers.
Do AS cause an over production of cholesterol (LDL) because cholesterol is so important for steroid hormone synthesis, that was my guess today...
So far, I've posted this in a few forums and no one has any answers...Even at M&M....
-
01-13-2009, 04:48 PM #333
Should healthy fats be used PWO?
I've been told they improve glycogen retention (which is what the body wants to do primarily PWO) and a small amount is needed for protein synthesis...?
-
01-13-2009, 04:49 PM #334
Whats the perfect amount of time to wait when doing rest/pause?
I've been told 10-15 seconds. Anything over that and the muscle will have recovered to much.
-
01-13-2009, 05:02 PM #335
What are your thoughts on TargeX? Do you think it works from scientific point of view?
-
01-13-2009, 05:33 PM #336
When I started working out about 2 years ago...I slowly sarted to notice my memory was getting bad and I was having a hard time concentrating. I feel it just keeps getting worse...and now it is to the point where I have a terrible vocabulary, and have to constantly word substitute. I cant even do the most basic of math because I cant get my mind to think. It is really starting to worry me. I dont know for sure if it was working out that caused this...but would there be any reason for it to make me dumb?
-
01-13-2009, 06:46 PM #337
-
01-13-2009, 07:10 PM #338
-
Damn You guys are not pulling any punches tonight. Give me a bit and i will answer all questions as best I can...
-
I actually like P90X, I have looked over it briefly and it seems fairly sound in its design. As long as you do the program and stick to it. I do not see any reason why it wouldnt help you get into decent shape for backpacking. Because much like hiking is not a static exercise neither is P90X.
-
-
These are all very good questions and I will try to answer them as specifically as I can. First off I have to say that cholesterol regulation/homostasis is not fully understood by science yet.
Second the mechanism by which steroid negative effect works seems to be influenced by the mode of entry in to the body.
LDL is theorized to be effected by The breakdown of VLDL's and by decreased activity in an enzyme called Lechthin-cholesterol acyltransfrase.
HDL is thought to be decrease because of the up-regulation of an enzyme in the liver that is believed to break down HDL's. This enzyme is called hepatic triglyceride lipase. 17alpha esterified oral compound such as Anavar have a much more pronounced effect than does 17beta esterfied orals or testosterone esters. Why that is exactly I could not find out specifically.
There is also some evidence that HMG-CoA reductase, which is an enzyme that is the rate limiting enzyme in the cholesterol synthesis pathway (rate limiting means that the reaction is controlled or bottle necked if you will by this enzyme) Is up-regulated by a family of organic molecules that cholesterol and anabolics are part of called sterols. When sterols are in high concentration in the blood. This enzyme will convert some of the sterol compounds (in this case steroids ) into cholesterol usually LDL.
SERM's are thought to effect cholesterol by increase the expression of a family of protiens in the liver known as Liver sterol-regulatory element binding proteins. These binding elements basically remove cholesterol from the blood stream by the liver where they are destroyed.
AI's in the most simply of explanations is thought to cause a negative effect on the lipid profile simple because of the negative effect it has on circulating estrogen in the body. In males the major source of estrogen is via aromatase activity and the conversion of androgens to estrogens. Estrogen has a positive effect on lipid profiles by raising HDL's and lowering LDL's. There may be other mechanisms at play but this seems to be the most important as far as AI's are concerned.
Keep in mind these are just a few of the mechanisms and were the most commonly sited in the literature. Believe me when I tell you there are more and are very complicated to understand....LOLLast edited by MuscleScience; 01-13-2009 at 11:49 PM. Reason: Sorry missed the AI question.
-
Well there are some studies out there that show it may be beneficial at promoting local fat loss. They used ultrasound analysis which I guess is ok, I would have preferred they use DXA scan but thats what I am most familiar with.
http://www.ncbi.nlm.nih.gov/pubmed/1...gdbfrom=pubmed
-
It sounds like you have either a thyroid problem or low testosterone levels just based on what you have stated. These are some of the clinical manifestations of these two conditions. However i am not an MD and I speak of these only on the exercise side of things, that I am trained to look for in athletes and other exercisers.
The other posters are right, typically people that workout have improved mental functions. I would certainly ask you doctor about it just to make sure nothing is out of whack.
Also extreme fatigue and over training can also cause some of these presentations.
-
01-14-2009, 12:31 PM #345
-
-
01-15-2009, 11:34 AM #347
Yup. Estrogen isnt that evil.
I know I'm kinda going further from exercise questions and more steroid and hormonal but I'll ask anyway...
I've been reading recently that SHBG really isnt bad at all. It seems one wants to reduce it during PCT, but not eliminate it becuase its very important for testosterone synthesis (what we want to increase during PCT), particularly cAMP. Its was said by BigCat and Nandi. Your thoughts?
I also dont think SHBG plays a big or crucial role in reducing gains when cycling for extended peroids. All steroids reduce SHBG to some extent. Even Testosterone.
So what are you thoughts on it and what role it plays.
Thanks mate.
-
I dont follow the link between cAMP and Testosterone. Both are cell messengers, cAMP is a G-Linked Second Messenger for adrenaline for example. Where as Testosterone is a intra-cellular messenger that freely passes through the cell membrane and attaches to the androgen receptor on the DNA. So a second messenger is not required for the cell to respond to the hormone as it is in the example of adrenaline and cAMP.
Maybe I am missing something here???Last edited by MuscleScience; 01-15-2009 at 09:45 PM.
-
01-16-2009, 11:42 AM #349
Hey Whats up Muscle Science?
Ok here is my question, I have been cutting for a while and was improving my lifts now most of them have halted.Im in a calorie deficit, so therefor i am mostly likely not going to build any new muscle right? im just lifting heavy to maintain my current muscle.right?
-
01-16-2009, 01:58 PM #350Associate Member
- Join Date
- Jul 2007
- Location
- The 7th Circle of Hell
- Posts
- 464
MS-
What do you consider an optimal number of exercises and sets per body part for muscle gain?
I.E. Chest - 4 exercises, 16 sets or whatever you think. I overtrained for years and now follow a less is more philosophy. Better to grow slowly than not at all.
-
-
It really depends on the muscle group that your working. For example the chest is not really considered a big muscle group yet some people will train it with the same volume as they would with legs or back. 3 to 4 exercise is probably about right for chest, sometimes people need a little more while some may need a little less. Its really a game of trial and error to be honest with you. I myself have problems with overtraining my chest, so I walk a very thin line between pushing it as much as I can and overdoing it.
I will write more on this a little later to be more specific on volume amounts for other muscle groups so check back later.
-
01-16-2009, 02:56 PM #353
I had that same question. Would like to see ur detailed answer dealing with other muscle groups especially biceps and shoulders.
Also just wondering why my biceps get sore from workouts that are not suppose to be targetting them.
I work out with a buddy of mine and we have the same routine. The days i work out my back, or triceps or chest when biceps work out is not included they end up feeling like i worked them as hard. while my friend doesn't have this issue.
Any light shed would be appreciated
( Oh if it helps im not on gear and i use to weigh 134lbs and the only little muscle i had was in my arms. now weigh 170lbs )
-
01-16-2009, 02:57 PM #354Associate Member
- Join Date
- Jul 2007
- Location
- The 7th Circle of Hell
- Posts
- 464
thanks. also interested in your opinion of all other groups.
-
If your doing any kind of rowing or retraction exercise when doing back, the biceps assist the movement. When doing chest the biceps are in an eccentric contraction (negative contraction) when performing an kind of press or flying exercise, same thing if your doing triceps dips.
To prevent overtraining do your biceps workout with your back workout. They are already being worked so might as well isolate and finish them off. This is what I do myself and when I train or if I design a workout for someone.
-
I will post a more detailed list on Monday or Tuesday, I have heard that NSCA may have changed their recommendations on training some and I need time to review any amendments that they have made so that I can provide you and everyone else with the most current literature on the subject, not just some personal dogma that a internet know-it-all is spitting out (ME)....LOL
So I hope you can bare with me until I review the new edition of their book that just came out.
-
01-16-2009, 11:29 PM #357
- Join Date
- Oct 2008
- Location
- Scamming my brothers
- Posts
- 11,286
- Blog Entries
- 2
So in a sense SHBG is not a bad thing under normal conditions, it can became a problem when androgen levels are low or someone is in a fasting state. The higher the levels the greater proportion of T that is being bound. Which if your trying to recover from a cycle would most likely be a bad thing. Since you may have high SHBG and lower T than normal.
The above statement is right up your alley Swifto - as this would seem to suggest proviron may be very prudent in a pct protocol....(and is often recommended in some as well)
-
yo MS.
This is food related, not exercise, but what the hell...
I keep reading conflicting articles on cooking(heating) with olive oil.
Some say yeah you can, it only changes the flavor, and others say its a bad idea because it goes over its smoke point???
What do you know my good man?
-
01-17-2009, 11:46 PM #359I keep reading conflicting articles on cooking(heating) with olive oil.
I got a q, what exactly is a cause of the distended stomach on hgh users? Is part of it from not adequately strengthening the abdominal muscles?
-
Thread Information
Users Browsing this Thread
There are currently 1 users browsing this thread. (0 members and 1 guests)
Erectile dysfunction after TRT,...
Yesterday, 11:37 AM in ANABOLIC STEROIDS - QUESTIONS & ANSWERS